When the pundits started floating MacKenzie Gore as a potential trade candidate, it seemed like confirmation that the Texas Rangers whiffed hard. After all, not only was Gore massively underwhelming, despite a couple of hot stretches, but it seemed as though there was no chance that they'd receive anything close to the value the five-prospect haul they gave up for him represented.
Here we are a few weeks later, and opinions have turned into actual rumors, with the Rangers fielding real calls about Gore's availability. The reality has changed, but so has the perception of what Texas could possibly receive for the enigmatic left-hander.
Gore's value seems to be rising, and Texas ironically has the Seattle Mariners to thank. The Mariners just dealt Bryce Miller (plus some odds and ends) to the Kansas City Royals for Maikel Garcia (plus some filler), and while that's a warning shot that Chris Young can't just sit on his hands, it's also an indication of where the trade market is really at with regard to starting pitchers.
Garcia is an exciting young player with Gold Glove defense who is signed to a below-market extension that runs through 2030 (2031 if his $21 million club option gets picked up). Miller doesn't hit free agency until 2030, while Gore is in the final year of his deal, but there's a case to be made that the Rangers' southpaw is the better hurler.
Miller has made more than 25 starts in a single season just once, produced a total of 0.9 fWAR over the past two seasons, and finished 2026 with 118 2/3 innings pitched, a 4.17 ERA, and a 4.41 FIP. Gore, on the other hand, produced 2.8 fWAR in 2026 alone while throwing 173 innings with a 4.58 ERA and a 3.87 FIP. He's clearly more durable, and one could argue he was a victim of bad luck while Miller had fortune on his side.
The kicker that really boosts Gore's value is what Seattle's president of baseball operations, Jerry Dipoto, said following the Miller-Garcia trade, as he made clear that there is "zero" chance that the Mariners trade another starting pitcher this offseason.
This is simple supply and demand, folks. Seattle has one of the league's greatest starting pitching surpluses, even after trading Miller, but if more deals for their rotation arms are off the table, then Gore's value will only rise.
The Mariners aren't the only reason why the Rangers can expect more in a MacKenzie Gore trade
You can't take the trade market and the free-agent market and look at them as separate beasts. They are carefully intertwined, and depending on what conditions are displayed in one, the other could become a more or less attractive avenue.
We haven't seen a ton of free-agent signings so far, but those that have gone down have shown that there is interest around the league in bolstering starting rotations. The deals that have been handed out prove that it's a good time to be a free-agent starter.
For example, the Chicago White Sox gave Dustin May a whopping three years and $52.5 million. May's a guy who was once a top prospect, struggled with horrific injury luck earlier in his career, and then posted a 4.96 ERA in 2025 and a 4.70 ERA in 2026. If that nets $17.5 million per year, then Gore's $8.7 million arbitration projection seems like a steal.
Then there's the case of Sonny Gray, who just inked a two-year, $55 million pact to return to the Minnesota Twins following a multi-year odyssey that took him to St. Louis and Boston. Gray was an ace for the Red Sox in 2026, posting a 2.72 ERA. However, he just turned 37; his 2026 performance was very much an outlier in the context of his 4.28 ERA in 2025 and 3.84 mark in 2024.
Another day, another Twins surprise.
— Aaron Gleeman (@AaronGleeman) November 18, 2026
And this one is a legit shocker, as the Twins are reuniting with Sonny Gray for $55 million.
My analysis: https://t.co/Zm9UHIgkmE
Paying that kind of money for an aging starter is a risk, and it further proves how desperate teams will do a lot ot get arms, especially ones that they think have high-end talent, into their rotations.
Going back to the Garcia trade, we see a roadmap that the Rangers can follow. Rather than flipping him for prospects, which would surely disappoint given what they gave up to get him, Texas might be able to swap him for a promising and cost-controlled big league asset at an actual position of need. Now, depending on how you feel about Cody Bradford, this would leave Texas's rotation looking light, but it could also be a way to solve a bigger roster issue, making a greater impact overall.
