The case for Rangers to re-sign frustrating relief pitcher

Relievers can experience intense ups and downs over the course of a long season. It is often hard to keep their total contributions in mind given the intense emotions a single appearance can provoke.

Former Texas Rangers reliever and current free agent Jose Leclerc saw a wide variety of outcomes during his time in Arlington. Whether or not he will remain with the club may ultimately hinge on if the front office can put up with his known weaknesses.

It is important to state the obvious. Leclerc has been a bullpen staple since 2016, and has spent his entire career with the Rangers. The Esperanza native holds a career ERA of 3.27 across 360.1 innings, and was a pivotal part of the Rangers' 2023 World Series run.

That Postseason, Leclerc earned a 3.29 ERA through 13.2 innings of work. He struck out 14 batters and walked six opponents during this stretch. Even though there were some tense moments, he did illustrate that his stuff could translate to October.

The case for Rangers to re-sign frustrating relief pitcher

The 30-year-old is coming off of a subpar season that saw him post a 4.32 ERA across 66.2 innings. He ranked in the 92nd percentile in K%, the 96th percentile in Hard Hit%, and the 14th percentile in BB%.

Leclerc lost the closer role to Kirby Yates early in 2024. He struggled to keep the bases empty, and issued too many free passes. Yates stepped in and made the role his own while the righty was forced to accept that he missed his chance.

Some insiders believe that a club like the Boston Red Sox could make a push for Leclerc this winter, but the Rangers will have to seriously consider bringing him back if it is a financial possibility.

Texas must find relievers this offseason. The righty has struggled with walks and certain high-leverage situations, but has also demonstrated an ability to strike hitters out and limit hard contact.

There is no guarantee that the Rangers will be able to find a reliever like Leclerc on the market. Further, it is possible that he would take a hometown discount. If the front office can stomach some of his shortcomings, it may be wise to keep Leclerc in the Lone Star State.