Rangers manager Skip Schumaker is sending a dangerous message to Justin Foscue

We get it. The 2026 game has become heavily predicated on statistics, advanced metrics, and splits. But sometimes, you just have to go with your gut and do what feels right instead of what the modalities are telling you.

In a rare easy Rangers win on Monday, when they defeated the Athletics 8-1 in a game that was never really in doubt, Justin Foscue hammered a 417-foot home run into the left-center field seats only to be pinch-hit for the next time through the order because the A's brought a right-handed reliever into the game.

What does a guy have to do for Schumaker to make a gut decision that isn't based on computer-generated probabilities and outcomes? Future Hall of Famer and former Rangers' manager Bruce Bochy wouldn't have dreamt of pulling Foscue after he hit a home run.

Skip Schumaker is going to impede Justin Foscue's growth as a hitter, despite his being part of the Rangers' future

Foscue has been clobbering left-handed pitching all year. His slash against them in 2026 is a Ruthian .319/.391/.622. On Monday, he got all of a Gage Jump fastball and drove it deep into the seats in left. The Rangers chased Jump from the game in the 4th inning and replaced by righty Chris Roycroft.

The next time through the lineup, when it was Foscue's turn to hit, he was called back in favor of Evan Carter, a lefty who is hitting all of .192 on the season.

Bochy used to reward hitters who went yard by not only leaving them in for the remainder of the game, but also giving them the start the next day - regardless of matchups and splits.

How is Foscue ever going to become a full-time non-platoon player if you don't show some faith in him? Schumaker needs to put the iPad down every once in a while and say, "Hey, nice job, my man! You are getting the at-bats for the rest of this game no matter what."

Eventually, Foscue is going to believe that he'll never hit righties and is destined to be a platoon lefty-killer for his entire career. This guy is having a breakout season with 10 homers and 137 OPS+. We're talking about a 27-year-old player who has been bouncing around from Frisco to Round Rock to Arlington for the better part of 4 years and is finally finding his footing as a big-leaguer.

Schumaker needs to show a little more faith in his guys and go with the hot hand instead of making decisions solely on what the computer is spouting out. Instill some confidence in guys who are getting the job done on the field.

Foscue is hitting just .178 this season against righties, so to an extent, it's understandable that Schumaker would want to protect him. However, that only comes over a sample of 78 plate appearances. It's hard to draw meaningful conclusions from that.

And in this example, Carter is hitting just .208 against righties. It's an improvement, but not by much. By pulling Foscue so early in the contest, Texas was left vulnerable to a lefty being brought in later to neutralize Carter as well.

Guys like Carter, and especially Joc Pederson, have frequently been used to pinch hit for Foscue in these situations, and while matching up has it's value, so too does playing the hot hand.

There's also the future to think about. Foscue is under team control through 2031, while Pederson is a free agent at the end of the season and likely won't be brought back. Wouldn't it be nice to know that Foscue can grab an everyday role next season? We never will if he isn't given a real shot to prove himself against righties.

We're not saying don't play the odds. Even if the hopes are dwindling, the Rangers are still in the playoff picture. But the odds sometimes are more nuanced than just righty-lefty splits. Sometimes, who's hot and who's not matters. We'd like to see Skip show a little more feel for that, and a little less fealty to the spreadsheets.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Follow